How Do I Run a Quick Debrief in Clinical Teaching?
A quick debrief is a short, structured conversation right after a patient encounter that helps a student reflect on what happened and decide what to do differently next time. This article gives clinical preceptors a four-step approach that fits into the few minutes between patients.
Before You Start: Preparation Checklist
- Know what you are watching for. Pick one or two objectives for the encounter before the student walks in, such as a complete entrance testing sequence or a clear presentation of findings.
- Tell the student a debrief is coming. Say up front that you will talk briefly afterward, and that the conversation is for learning, not for a grade.
- Find a private spot. Debrief away from the patient and out of earshot of the waiting area.
- Plan for five to ten minutes. Structured clinical debriefs reported in emergency care took about five minutes with one tool and about eleven minutes on average in a larger study (Edinburgh Emergency Medicine; Coggins et al., 2020).
The Four Steps of a Quick Debrief
These steps come from a model that treats debriefing as formative assessment: the goal is to find the gap between what the student did and what you hoped to see, and then help close it (Rudolph et al., 2008).
Note the performance gap.
While you observe, compare what the student does with the objectives you set beforehand. You will usually see several gaps. Choose the one that matters most for this student and this patient.
Describe the gap out loud.
Tell the student plainly what you saw and what you expected to see. Keep it specific to the action, not the person.
Example: “I noticed you dilated before checking pupils. I was expecting pupils first, because we can’t assess for an afferent defect once the patient is dilated.”
Ask what was behind it.
Explore the thinking and the feelings that led to the action. The same mistake can come from a knowledge gap, a time-pressure decision, or nerves, and each one needs a different fix.
Example: “Walk me through what you were thinking when you reached for the drops.”
Help close the gap.
Once you know the cause, discuss it or teach the relevant principle or skill in a minute or two. Finish by agreeing on one thing the student will do with the next patient.
Other Quick Frameworks You Can Use
If the four steps do not suit the moment, these frameworks give you a ready-made set of questions.
- Plus/Delta: What went well? What would you like to change? How would you change it? This is the fastest option when you only have two minutes (Jeffries, as described in Fegran et al., 2023).
- Example (Plus/Delta after a contact lens fitting):
“What went well in that fit?” “What would you change about how you explained insertion and removal?” “How will you do that with your next patient?”
- Example (Plus/Delta after a contact lens fitting):
- S.T.O.P.: Developed by an emergency department team as a five-minute debrief (Edinburgh Emergency Medicine; used in Coggins et al., 2020):
- Summarise the case,
- Things that went well,
- Opportunities for improvement,
- Points of action.
- PEARLS: Blend three strategies as needed: the student’s self-assessment, a focused discussion, and direct feedback or teaching (Eppich and Cheng, as described in Fegran et al., 2023).
- 3D Model: Defusing, Discovering, Deepening. This one makes room for the student’s emotional reaction first, which helps after a difficult encounter (Zigmont and colleagues, as described in Fegran et al., 2023).
IMPORTANT: No single framework has been shown to work best. A review of 140 studies of debriefing in nursing education found no consensus on which one to use (Fegran et al., 2023). The research behind this article comes from medicine and nursing, not optometry, so pick the framework that fits your clinic and use it consistently.
Best Practices
- Debrief soon. Talk while the encounter is fresh, ideally before the next patient.
- Let the student go first. Open with their own assessment of the encounter before you give yours.
- Keep it confidential and open. Students reflect honestly only when they trust that the conversation stays between you and is meant to help them.
- Stick to one or two points. A short debrief cannot cover everything. Save the rest for another encounter.
- End with an action. The student should leave knowing exactly what to try next time.
Troubleshooting Common Issues
Issue: There is no time between patients.
Solution: Use Plus/Delta and limit it to one “plus” and one “delta.” If even that will not fit, tell the student when you will debrief later that day.
Issue: The student goes quiet or gets defensive.
Solution: Remind them the debrief is for learning, not grading. Then return to step 3 and ask what they were thinking, without correcting them right away.
Issue: You notice you are doing all the talking.
Solution: Stop and ask a question. The student’s explanation tells you what to teach, so you need to hear it before you move to step 4.
Issue: The encounter was upsetting for the student.
Solution: Let the student talk about how it felt before you discuss performance, as in the “Defusing” phase of the 3D Model. Follow up later if they need more support.
Self-Check Questions
- Did I decide what I was watching for before the encounter?
- Did I describe what I saw in specific terms?
- Did I ask about the student’s thinking before I started teaching?
- Did the student leave with one clear action for the next patient?
Additional Resources
- Rudolph, J. W., Simon, R., Raemer, D. B., & Eppich, W. J. (2008). Debriefing as formative assessment: Closing performance gaps in medical education. Academic Emergency Medicine, 15(11), 1010–1016.
- Fegran, L., ten Ham-Baloyi, W., Fossum, M., Hovland, O. J., Naidoo, J. R., van Rooyen, D., Sejersted, E., & Robstad, N. (2023). Simulation debriefing as part of simulation for clinical teaching and learning in nursing education: A scoping review. Nursing Open, 10, 1217–1233.
- Coggins, A., De Los Santos, A., Zaklama, R., & Murphy, M. (2020). Interdisciplinary clinical debriefing in the emergency department: An observational study of learning topics and outcomes. BMC Emergency Medicine, 20.
- Edinburgh Emergency Medicine. STOP 5: Stop for 5 minutes – our bespoke hot debrief model.
Need Extra Support?
If you would like help building quick debriefs into your precepting, reach out to the TLC team.
-
- Email: tlc@neco.edu
- Send us a request: Request Support